What should I get next?

[Tsukiyomi]

I would go for swadian gauntlets and an elegant crossbow.  Getting better gauntlets is usually a much cheaper way to increase your armor value without adding extra weight.  Next would be Bronze bolts; the extra damage and ammo capacity is great.  Once you have those things I would go for crossed (I know you don't think 4 armor is worth it but trust me, it is) and then a hero class crossbow, either the big shot or eastern repeater depending on your preferred play style.  As Dr mentioned in an earlier post you could also craft a Heroes Mercy.  It's a beautiful weapon but if you don't find yourself in melee much I would go for the other items I've mentioned first.  Hope this helps.