Halberdier Change

[Irolltwenties]

But can you please tell me why it would make sense to give a class with shit 1H ability and shit armor exceptionally high shield skill?
There's just no synergy in your idea.
I'd much rather prefer the Halberdier to get some more melee and ranged power or better crafteable armor options than just giving it some random ability.

Btw: Comparing Polearms with Twohands and just saying one or the other is better is bullshit.
Mjolnir is much shorter than a Pike of Kings and has a completely different area of use.
Also taking a Dragon Halberd as counterpart to a Durendal is pretty silly since the Naval Glaive behaves much more similar than the sword and actually does more damage.

It wasn't my argument it was his.  I was just refuting it.  I also made a correction.  The ad hominem accusation is also funny to me, it's clear he was attempting to weaken my position and argument by accusing me of fallacy and personal attacks.

Anyway the community seems to think it's a bad idea.  It would be pretty silly to change anything based on one person's views when so many people think differently.  I will surrender my assumptions to the majority view.