(05-09-2013, 02:16 AM)Sparhawk link Wrote: Just a comparison, and Reskan, some of your figures are off:Take into account who can use them. The Tower Shield is a great shield, but very low in value compared to its stats simply because it is Sharpshooter only. Fell Edge is everyone, Illustrious is only for Sentinel, Aventurier, and Legionnaire. The first two are hardly played at all and I cannot think of anyone that has them other than myself. Legionnaire is a little bit more popular, but not by much, and most people playing it use Very Heavy Throwing Axes and would prefer the extra slot of ammo over a 1h. My two cents on it.
Fell Edge:
Speed 102
Weapon Length 80
Swing Damage 57 (Cut)
Illustrious
Speed 104
Length 99
Swing Damage 52 (Cut)
Thrust Damage 36 (Pierce)
So, Illustrious vs Fell Edge
+2 Speed
+19 Length
- 5 Cut
+36 Pierce
In my opinion, these two weapons would be about equal in value. The only downside to Illustrious is that it is a Hero only weapon.
Also one some of your figures are off, Fell Edge is 58 cut and Illustrious is 57c, 37p, and 103 speed (unless it has been changed since Reskan posted and I was not informed). Let the man value it however he wants, and if you want to correct his price send him a PM or something.