Question's about Extra Hp

[Forward]

I am really getting tired of reading this every time whenever infantry, extra health or anything related is brought up.
Do you see servers dominated by melee classes? I don't. The amount of times I have seen more melee classes on a server then ranged is close to zero, special events excluded.
Can infantry, in melee, kite on hard or ragnarok servers? Possibly, but again I think the chance is close to zero.
If you really want to see ranged only, go play a FPS.
Knock it off by keep on mentioning it, my patience has run dry.

I can tell you from my own experience why I don't play infantry all time. It's too easy. That's all.

I have infantry and pikeman heroes. And I don't understand why it's called balance when as pike I afraid to die from any spit into my side, and as inf I can face tank everything, spam heal and run ahead. It's too easy and boring for me to play this way. I don't know why you think it's balanced.

Question is not even about balancing melee and ranged classes, I can live with melee classes have more hp. Problem you declared infntry as only melee classes above all others and it's unfair to Pike Heroes, Pavise Champions, Aventuriers and even to some extent to non-Warden archers (I would really not against them having 50% more HP, it will not change anything in scale how they suck anyway).

Did not have that experience with my hoplite(not using shield).

Would be more fair if Hoplite has some extra HP too.

If it can't removed, it should be distributed more fair/evenly amonst the classes. Classes with more ranged abilities should get less extra HP and such. Not as now when infantry heroes are superhumans above everyone else.